Cholecystocutaneous Fistula
- Author: Cherry Ee Peck Koh, FRACS, MBBS, MS; Chief Editor: John Geibel, MD, DSc, MA more...
Background
Biliary fistulae can be divided into internal and external biliary fistulae. External biliary fistulae, in turn, can be further subdivided based on etiology into spontaneous, therapeutic, traumatic, and iatrogenic fistulae. Spontaneous external cholecystocutaneous fistula is a rare surgical complication of neglected calculous biliary disease that has become even increasingly rarer because of prompt diagnosis and expedient surgical intervention for gallstones.
Thilesus first described cholecystocutaneous fistula in 1670.[1] Prior to 1900, 3 large series were published in quick succession, including a report by Courvoisier in 1890 (169 of 499 cases of gallbladder perforation), 1 by Naunyn in 1896 (184 cases), and another by Bonnet in 1897 (122 cases).[2, 3, 4, 5]
History of the Procedure
Since the advent of surgical treatment of gallbladder calculous disease, the incidence of cholecystocutaneous fistula has reduced dramatically; from 1890-1949, only 37 cases were identified in the published literature.[5] A literature review of cases published in the last 50 years reveals fewer than 50 cases (see Table). The declining incidence has been attributed to prompt diagnosis, availability of antibiotics, and early surgical intervention for cholecystitis and empyema (see Pathophysiology). The decreasing incidence is further confirmed by the availability of large series published prior to the 20th century, in contrast to more recent literature, which consists mainly of individual case reports.
Table. Case Reports of Cholecystocutaneous Fistula in the Past 50 Years From 1961 to 2011 (Open Table in a new window)
| Author(s) | Year Published | Number of Cases | Country of Origin |
| Gordon et al[6] | 2011 | 1 | United States of America |
| Sayed et al[7] | 2010 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Pezzilli et al[8] | 2010 | 1 | Italy |
| Metsemakers et al[9] | 2010 | 1 | Belgium |
| Tallon Aquilar et al[10] | 2010 | 1 | Spain |
| Hawari et al[11] | 2010 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Gandhi et al[12] | 2009 | 1 | New Zealand |
| Murphy et al[13] | 2008 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Ijaz et al[14] | 2008 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Chatterjee et al[15] | 2007 | 1 | India |
| Malik et al[16] | 2007 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Nagral et al[17] | 2007 | 1 | India |
| Marwah et al[18] | 2007 | 1 | India |
| Shrestha et al[19] | 2006 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Cruz et al[20] | 2006 | 1 | Brazil |
| Salvador-Izquierdo et al[21] | 2006 | 1 | Spain |
| Yuceyar et al[22] | 2005 | 1 | Turkey |
| Khan et al[23] | 2005 | 1 | Saudi Arabia |
| Dutriaux et al[24] | 2005 | 1 | France |
| Gossage et al[25] | 2004 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Vasanth et al[26] | 2004 | 1 | United States of America |
| Mathonnet et al[27] | 2002 | 1 | France |
| Chang et al[28] | 2002 | 1 | Taiwan |
| Flora et al[29] | 2001 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Ramos Rincon et al[30] | 2001 | 1 | Spain |
| Nicholson et al[31] | 1999 | 1 | United States of America |
| Avital et al[32] | 1998 | 1 | Israel |
| Kumar[33] | 1998 | 1 | United States of America |
| Andley et al[34] | 1996 | 1 | India |
| Birch et al[35] | 1991 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Carragher et al[36] | 1990 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Rosario et al[37] | 1990 | 1 | United States of America |
| Sevonius et al[38] | 1988 | 1 | Sweden |
| Gibson et al[39] | 1987 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Bilanovic et al[40] | 1987 | 1 | Croatia |
| Tuna et al[41] | 1986 | 1 | United States of America |
| Hakaim et al[42] | 1986 | 1 | United States of America |
| Rye et al[43] | 1985 | 1 | Denmark |
| Kulicki et al[44] | 1984 | 1 | Poland |
| Davies et al[45] | 1984 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Abril et al[46] | 1984 | 1 | United States of America |
| Nayman[47] | 1983 | 1 | Australia |
| Ulreich et al[48] | 1983 | 1 | United States of America |
| Hoffman et al[49] | 1982 | 1 | United States of America |
| Fitchett et al[50] | 1970 | 1 | United States of America |
| Callen[51] | 1979 | 1 | United States of America |
| Orr[52] | 1979 | 1 | Australia |
Problem
A fistula is an epithelium-lined tract between 2 epithelium-lined surfaces. Thus, a cholecystocutaneous fistula is an abnormal epithelial tract that allows communication between the gallbladder and the skin. This communication can be either spontaneous or deliberate as in the case of a therapeutic percutaneous cholecystostomy used to treat cholecystitis or empyema of the gallbladder, which is generally reserved for patients unfit for surgical intervention, while the former is often a complication of neglected gallstone disease.
Epidemiology
Frequency
Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula is rare. No data exist for the incidence of this condition in the United States. In a retrospective review in Greece, of 210 cases of external biliary fistulae over a 22-year period, only 1 was due to spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula.[53]
To emphasize the rarity of this condition, from 1890-1949, only 37 published cases were found worldwide. After a careful search of indexed and nonindexed journals, fewer than 50 cases have been reported worldwide (see Table above). A closer look at the Table also reveals that just over half the cases have been reported in the past 10 years, which reflects the increased number of avenues for publication of case reports and recognition that the condition is rare.
Etiology
This condition is invariably a complication of neglected gallstone disease, although isolated case reports have described spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula due to carcinoma of the gallbladder and acalculous cholecystitis.[54]Carcinoma of the gallbladder can cause cystic duct obstruction, which leads to inflammation in a manner similar to that of gallstones.[55]
In addition, retained gallstones following laparoscopic cholecystectomy may cause biliary fistula or abdominal wall sinuses. This occurs because gallstones can harbor bacteria, which may form a localized abscess with fistula or sinus in an attempt to discharge the foreign body.[56, 57] Although this is relatively uncommon despite a relatively common occurrence of stone spillage, some authors recommend the liberal use of retrieval bags during surgery to avoid stone spillage and subsequent complications of retained stones.[58]
Salmonella typhi, which has a predilection for the gallbladder, can cause chronic cholecystitis and may predispose the patient to spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula.[59] Polyarteritis nodosa with gallbladder vasculitis and steroid use causing immunosuppression also may be associated with the condition.[59]
Pathophysiology
The cystic duct or gallbladder is almost always obstructed in patients with spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. In the presence of obstruction, the gallbladder distends and the pressure within rises, impairing the vascular supply. The obstruction and impaired blood supply result in inflammation and may cause focal areas of necrosis. This inflammatory process is typically insidious and recurrent. Surrounding structures wall off the focal area of necrosis. Perforation of the gallbladder may occur, causing a localized cholecystic abscess. In an attempt to discharge this abscess, a fistula may thus form between the gallbladder and the duodenum, colon, or abdominal wall.
In spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula, the abscess is walled off by the abdominal wall and progressively penetrates it. The fistula usually occurs via the fundus of the gallbladder, as this is the farthest from the cystic artery and most likely to be affected in inflammation-caused ischemia. The cholecystic abscess may initially cause a tender area in the abdominal wall and spontaneously rupture, forming a fistula with drainage onto the skin.
Because of the anatomy and position of the gallbladder, the gallbladder much more commonly adheres to neighboring viscera, such as the duodenum and colon, forming cholecystoduodenal fistula that predisposes to gallstone ileus or cholecystocolonic fistula. Similar to cholecystocutaneous fistula, the incidence of cholecystoduodenal fistula is also declining because of expedient surgical intervention.
Presentation
Epidemiology
Patients tend to be elderly, although cholecystocutaneous fistulae have been reported as early as the third decade of life. Younger patients are likely to have neglected their symptoms for a period of time or have neuropathy that causes altered sensation.[60] Women are affected more than men, reflecting the higher incidence of cholelithiasis and cholecystitis among women.
History
Most patients have a history suggestive of biliary disease; however, these symptoms are unlikely to be severe, as an acute attack would have precipitated early presentation for surgical intervention. Depending on the stage of progression, patients may present with empyema necessitatis or a discharging sinus.[61] Empyema necessitatis simply refers to a cholecystic abscess prior to rupture. The patient may report systemic symptoms, such as fevers, sweats, and anorexia associated with the infection, or a tender lump at the site of impending perforation. Patients in whom fistulae have discharged may report loss of bilious fluid or small stones via the external opening. The fistula itself is usually painless.
Examination
The patient may be febrile and diaphoretic because of the infection. Prior to rupture, a raised, erythematous, tender, hot area of affected skin may be observed (see the image below). The surrounding skin is often cellulitic, frequently leading to an initial diagnosis of abscess. An associated lump under the skin may be observed if the gallbladder has herniated through the overlying tissue or if an associated malignancy is present.
A 90-year-old man referred with abdominal wall abscess in the right upper quadrant. The external opening is usually in the right upper quadrant, although external openings in the periumbilical area, the lumbar area, and even the gluteal area have been described. The discharge varies depending on whether an obstruction is present. Discharge may be purulent in the presence of empyema, mucoid in the presence of a mucocele because of obstruction, or bilious in the absence of obstruction. Small stones within the discharge often confirm the diagnosis.
Differential diagnosis
- Infected epidermal inclusion cyst
- Discharging tuberculoma
- Pyogenic granuloma
- Chronic osteomyelitis of ribs with sequestrum
- Metastatic carcinoma
Relevant Anatomy
See Pathophysiology.
Horhammer Cl. Ueber estraperitoneale perforatio der Gallenblase. Munchener Medizinische Wochenschrift. October 1916;10:1451-1452.
Courvoisier L. Pathologie and Chirurgie der Gallenwege. Leipzig, Germany: FCW Vogel; 1890.
Naunyn B. Ulcerative affections of the biliary passage and fistula formation. In: A Treatise on Cholelithiasis. New Syndenham Society; (English version 1896). New Syndenham Society; 1892:138-151.
Bonnet. Fistule biliaire cutanee. Lyon Med. 1897;85.
Henry CL, Orr TG. Spontaneous external biliary fistulas. Surgery. 1949;26(4):641-646.
Gordon PE, Miller DL, Rattner DW, Conrad C. Cholecystocutaneous fistula (Jean-Louis Petit phlegmon). Arch Surg. Apr 2011;146(4):487-8. [Medline].
Sayed L, Sangal S, Finch G. Spontaneous Cholecystocutaneous Fistula: A Rare Presentation of Gallstones. In: JSCR. 2010.
Pezzilli R, Barakat B, Corinaldesi R, Cavazza M. Spontaneous Cholecystocutaneous Fistula. Case Rep Gastroenterol. Sep 15 2010;4(3):356-360. [Medline]. [Full Text].
Metsemakers WJ, Quanten I, Vanhoenacker F, Spiessens T. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous abscess. JBR-BTR. Jul-Aug 2010;93(4):198-200. [Medline].
Tallon Aguilar L, Lopez Porras M, Molina Garcia D, Bustos Jimenez M, Tamayo Lopez MJ. Cholecystocutaneous fistula: a rare complication of gallstones. Gastroenterol Hepatol. Aug-Sep 2010;33(7):553-4. [Medline].
Hawari M, Wemyss-Holden S, Parry GW. Recurrent chest wall abscesses overlying a pneumonectomy scar: an unusual presentation of a cholecystocutaneous fistula. Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. May 2010;10(5):828-9. [Medline].
Abdominal wall abscess – More Than Meets The Eye. The Internet Journal of Surgery, 2009. Available at http://www.ispub.com/journal/the_internet_journal_of_surgery/volume_20_number_1_1/article_printable/abdominal-wall-abscess-more-than-meets-the-eye.html. Accessed June 2011.
Murphy JA, Vimalachandran CD, Howes N, Ghaneh P. Anterior abdominal wall abscess secondary to subcutaneous gallstones. Case Rep Gastroenterol. Jul 9 2008;2(2):219-23. [Medline]. [Full Text].
Ijaz S, Lidder S, Mohamid W, Thompson HH. Cholecystocutaneous fistula secondary to chronic calculous cholecystitis. Case Rep Gastroenterol. Mar 11 2008;2(1):71-5. [Medline]. [Full Text].
Chatterjee S, Choudhuri T, Ghosh G, Ganguly A. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula in a case of chronic colculous cholecystitis--a case report. J Indian Med Assoc. Nov 2007;105(11):644, 646, 656. [Medline].
Malik AH, Nadeem M, Ockrim J. Complete laparoscopic management of cholecystocutaneous fistula. Ulster Med J. Sep 2007;76(3):166-7. [Medline]. [Full Text].
Spontaneous Cholecystocutaneous Fistula. Bombay Hosp J, 2007. Available at http://www.bhj.org/journal/2007_4904_oct/html/spontaneous_cholecystocutaneous_fistula_684-685.html. Accessed June 2011.
Marwah S, Godara R, Sandhu D, Karwasra R. Spontaneous gallbladder perforation presenting as abdominal wall abscess. In: Internet J Surg. 2007.
Shrestha BM, Wyman A. Cholecystocolocutaneous fistula: a case report. Hepatobiliary Pancreat Dis Int. Aug 2006;5(3):462-4. [Medline].
Cruz RJ Jr, Nahas J, de Figueiredo LF. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula: a rare complication of gallbladder disease. Sao Paulo Med J. Jul 6 2006;124(4):234-6. [Medline].
Salvador-Izquierdo R, Gimeno-Solsona F. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula in the ederly. Med Clin (Barc). Sep 9 2006;127(9):359. [Medline].
Yuceyar S, Erturk S, Karabicak I, Onur E, Aydogan F. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula presenting with an abscess containing multiple gallstones: a case report. Mt Sinai J Med. Nov 2005;72(6):402-4. [Medline].
Khan AA, Azhar MZ, Khan AA, Rasheed A, Khan KN. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. Nov 2005;15(11):726-7. [Medline].
Dutriaux C, Maillard H, Prophette B, Catala M, Celerier P. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. Ann Dermatol Venereol. May 2005;132(5):467-9. [Medline].
Gossage J, Forshaw M, Stephenson J, Mason R. Spontaneous Cholecysto-cutaneous fistula. J Surg. 2004;2:52-3.
Vasanth A, Siddiqui A, O'Donnell K. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. South Med J. Feb 2004;97(2):183-5. [Medline].
Mathonnet M, Maisonnette F, Gainant A, Cubertafond P. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula: natural history of biliary cholecystitis. Ann Chir. May 2002;127(5):378-80. [Medline].
Chang SS, Lu CL, Pan CC, et al. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula presenting with a cellulitis and portal vein thrombosis. J Clin Gastroenterol. Jan 2002;34(1):99-100. [Medline].
Flora HS, Bhattacharya S. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. HPB (Oxford). 2001;3(4):279-80. [Medline]. [Full Text].
Ramos Rincon JM, Fernandez Frias A, Costa Navarro D, et al. Spontaneous bilio-cutaneous fistula. A rare clinical entity. Gastroenterol Hepatol. Oct 2001;24(8):411-2. [Medline].
Nicholson T, Born MW, Garber E. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula presenting in the gluteal region. J Clin Gastroenterol. Apr 1999;28(3):276-7. [Medline].
Avital S, Greenberg R, Goldwirth M, Werbin N, Skornik Y. A spontaneous discharging wound on the abdominal wall. Postgrad Med J. Aug 1998;74(874):505-6. [Medline]. [Full Text].
Kumar SS. Laparoscopic management of a cholecystocutaneous abscess. Am Surg. Dec 1998;64(12):1192-4. [Medline].
Andley M, Biswas RS, Ashok S, Somshekar G, Gulati SM. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula secondary to calculous cholecystitis. Am J Gastroenterol. Aug 1996;91(8):1656-7. [Medline].
Birch BR, Cox SJ. Spontaneous external biliary fistula uncomplicated by gallstones. Postgrad Med J. Apr 1991;67(786):391-2. [Medline]. [Full Text].
Carragher AM, Jackson PR, Panesar KJ. Subcutaneous herniation of gall-bladder with spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. Clin Radiol. Oct 1990;42(4):283-4. [Medline].
Rosario PG, Gerst PH, Prakash K, Katter H. Cholecystocutaneous fistula: an unusual presentation. Am J Gastroenterol. Feb 1990;85(2):214-5. [Medline].
Sevonius D, Johannesson E. Gluteal abscess shown to be a cholecystocutaneous fistula. Lakartidningen. Mar 23 1988;85(12):1061. [Medline].
Gibson TC, Howat JM. Cholecystocutaneous fistula. Br J Clin Pract. Oct 1987;41(10):980-2. [Medline].
Bilanovic D, Colovic R. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. Acta Chir Iugosl. 1987;34(1):65-8. [Medline].
Tuna IC, Maizel S, O'Connor M, Humphrey EW. Simultaneous cholecystocutaneous and cholecystoduodenal fistulae. Minn Med. Feb 1986;69(2):77-8. [Medline].
Hakaim AG, Vogt DP. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistulas. Cleve Clin Q. Winter 1986;53(4):363-5. [Medline].
Rye B, Jorgensen U. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. Ugeskr Laeger. Jul 15 1985;147(29):2305-6. [Medline].
Kulicki M. Case of cholecystocutaneous fistula. Wiad Lek. Jun 15 1984;37(12):955-7. [Medline].
Davies CJ, Fontaine CJ. Spontaneous cholecysto-umbilical fistula. Br J Radiol. Nov 1984;57(683):1034-6. [Medline].
Abril A, Ulfohn A. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. South Med J. Sep 1984;77(9):1192-3. [Medline].
NAYMAN J. Empyema necessitatis of the gall-bladder. Med J Aust. Mar 23 1963;1:429-30. [Medline].
Ulreich S, Henken EM, Levinson ED. Imaging in the diagnosis of cholecystocutaneous fistulae. J Can Assoc Radiol. Mar 1983;34(1):39-41. [Medline].
Hoffman L, Beaton H, Wantz G. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula: a complication of neglected biliary tract disease. J Am Geriatr Soc. Oct 1982;30(10):632-4. [Medline].
Fitchett CW. Spontaneous external biliary fistula. Va Med Mon (1918). Sep 1970;97(9):538-43. [Medline].
Callen JP. Cholecystocutaneous fistula. Int J Dermatol. Jan-Feb 1979;18(1):63-4. [Medline].
Orr KB. Spontaneous external biliary fistula. Aust N Z J Surg. Oct 1979;49(5):584-5. [Medline].
Dadoukis J, Prousalidis J, Botsios D, Tzartinoglou E, Apostolidis S, Papadopoulos V, et al. External biliary fistula. HPB Surg. 1998;10(6):375-7. [Medline].
Chang SS, Lu CL, Pan CC, Chiou YY, Wang SS, Chang FY, et al. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula presenting with a cellulitis and portal vein thrombosis. J Clin Gastroenterol. Jan 2002;34(1):99-100. [Medline].
Vasanth A, Siddiqui A, O'Donnell K. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. South Med J. Feb 2004;97(2):183-5. [Medline].
Lau MW, Hall CN, Brown TH. Biliary-cutaneous fistula: an uncommon complication of retained gallstones following laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Surg Laparosc Endosc. Apr 1996;6(2):150-1. [Medline].
Weiler H, Grandel A. Postoperative fistula of the abdominal wall after laparoscopic cholecystectomy due to lost gallstones. Eur J Ultrasound. Jun 2002;15(1-2):61-3. [Medline].
Shrestha BM, Wyman A. Cholecystocolocutaneous fistula: a case report. Hepatobiliary Pancreat Dis Int. Aug 2006;5(3):462-4. [Medline].
Birch BR, Cox SJ. Spontaneous external biliary fistula uncomplicated by gallstones. Postgrad Med J. Apr 1991;67(786):391-2. [Medline].
Hoffman L, Beaton H, Wantz G. Spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula: a complication of neglected biliary tract disease. J Am Geriatr Soc. Oct 1982;30(10):632-4. [Medline].
Nayman J. Empyema necessitatis of the gall bladder. Med J Australia. 1963;1: 429.
Carragher AM, Jackson PR, Panesar KJ. Subcutaneous herniation of gall-bladder with spontaneous cholecystocutaneous fistula. Clin Radiol. Oct 1990;42(4):283-4. [Medline].
Kumar SS. Laparoscopic management of a cholecystocutaneous abscess. Am Surg. Dec 1998;64(12):1192-4. [Medline].
Davies MG, Tadros E, Gaine S, McEntee GP, Gorey TF, Hennessy TP. Combined internal and external biliary fistulae treated by percutaneous cholecystlithotomy. Br J Surg. Dec 1989;76(12):1258. [Medline].
Gifford J, Saltztein SL, Barone RM. Adenocarcinoma occurring in association with a chronic sinus tract and biliary fistula. Cancer. 1981;15:2903-7.
| Author(s) | Year Published | Number of Cases | Country of Origin |
| Gordon et al[6] | 2011 | 1 | United States of America |
| Sayed et al[7] | 2010 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Pezzilli et al[8] | 2010 | 1 | Italy |
| Metsemakers et al[9] | 2010 | 1 | Belgium |
| Tallon Aquilar et al[10] | 2010 | 1 | Spain |
| Hawari et al[11] | 2010 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Gandhi et al[12] | 2009 | 1 | New Zealand |
| Murphy et al[13] | 2008 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Ijaz et al[14] | 2008 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Chatterjee et al[15] | 2007 | 1 | India |
| Malik et al[16] | 2007 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Nagral et al[17] | 2007 | 1 | India |
| Marwah et al[18] | 2007 | 1 | India |
| Shrestha et al[19] | 2006 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Cruz et al[20] | 2006 | 1 | Brazil |
| Salvador-Izquierdo et al[21] | 2006 | 1 | Spain |
| Yuceyar et al[22] | 2005 | 1 | Turkey |
| Khan et al[23] | 2005 | 1 | Saudi Arabia |
| Dutriaux et al[24] | 2005 | 1 | France |
| Gossage et al[25] | 2004 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Vasanth et al[26] | 2004 | 1 | United States of America |
| Mathonnet et al[27] | 2002 | 1 | France |
| Chang et al[28] | 2002 | 1 | Taiwan |
| Flora et al[29] | 2001 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Ramos Rincon et al[30] | 2001 | 1 | Spain |
| Nicholson et al[31] | 1999 | 1 | United States of America |
| Avital et al[32] | 1998 | 1 | Israel |
| Kumar[33] | 1998 | 1 | United States of America |
| Andley et al[34] | 1996 | 1 | India |
| Birch et al[35] | 1991 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Carragher et al[36] | 1990 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Rosario et al[37] | 1990 | 1 | United States of America |
| Sevonius et al[38] | 1988 | 1 | Sweden |
| Gibson et al[39] | 1987 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Bilanovic et al[40] | 1987 | 1 | Croatia |
| Tuna et al[41] | 1986 | 1 | United States of America |
| Hakaim et al[42] | 1986 | 1 | United States of America |
| Rye et al[43] | 1985 | 1 | Denmark |
| Kulicki et al[44] | 1984 | 1 | Poland |
| Davies et al[45] | 1984 | 1 | United Kingdom |
| Abril et al[46] | 1984 | 1 | United States of America |
| Nayman[47] | 1983 | 1 | Australia |
| Ulreich et al[48] | 1983 | 1 | United States of America |
| Hoffman et al[49] | 1982 | 1 | United States of America |
| Fitchett et al[50] | 1970 | 1 | United States of America |
| Callen[51] | 1979 | 1 | United States of America |
| Orr[52] | 1979 | 1 | Australia |

